Money for The Rest of Us

Investment help and financial guidance for the rest of us.

  • Podcast
  • Guides
        • Asset Classes

        • A Complete Guide to Investing in I Bonds and TIPS (2025)
        • A Complete Guide to Equity REIT Investing
        • A Complete Guide to Mortgage REIT Investing
        • A Complete Guide to Investing in Gold
        • A Complete Guide To Investing In Convertible Bonds
        • Investing in Bitcoin, Oil, and Volatility ETFs
        • Carbon Investing and its Effect on Climate Change
        • Farmland Investing
        • The Opportunity and Risk of Frontier Markets
        • Investment Vehicles

        • A Complete Guide to Investment Vehicles
        • How to Invest in Closed-End Funds
        • What Are SPACs and Should You Invest in Them?
        • Money and Economics

        • A Complete Guide to Understanding and Protecting Against Inflation
        • Understanding Web3 Investing
        • Strategy

        • Why You Should Rebalance Your Portfolio
        • What Is Risk vs Uncertainty?
        • Tail Events and Tail Risk
  • Resources
        • General Resources

        • Topic Index
        • Glossary
        • Most Influential Books
        • Member Tools

        • Member - Getting Started Guide
        • Asset Allocation and Portfolio Tools
        • Current Investment Strategy Report
        • All Investment Conditions Reports
        • Strategic and Adaptive Model Portfolios
        • Member Tools and Downloads
        • Member Resources

        • Plus Premium Episodes
        • Submit A Question to the Plus Podcast
        • Member Forums
        • David’s Current Portfolio
        • David's Portfolio Trades
        • Courses

        • Investing in Closed-End Funds
  • Members
  • Join
  • Log In
You are here: Home / Podcast / 58: Are ETFs and Indexing Becoming Too Popular?

58: Are ETFs and Indexing Becoming Too Popular?

May 27, 2015 by David Stein · Updated November 2, 2020

What are the hidden risks of ETFs and passive investing.

etfs-850


In this episode, you’ll learn:

  1. What is the size of the ETF market relative to mutual funds.
  2. What percent of funds and ETFs are passively managed.
  3. What is market capitalization.
  4. How ETFs differ from mutual funds in how they trade.
  5. What is net asset value.
  6. What is the arbitrage mechanism that keeps ETFs market prices close to their net asset values.
  7. How new ETFs are created and redeemed.
  8. How ETFs are causing increased market volatility.
  9. How reduced liquidity for securities held by ETFs is increasing systemic risk.
  10. The systemic risks of leveraged ETFs.
  11. What are the risks of passive indexing.

Show Notes

Exchange Traded Funds and Market Volatility: The Case of the S&P 500 Index by Lio Xu and Xiankang Ying

It’s Easy To Beat The Market by Moshe Levy

The Social Science Research Network

Become a Better Investor With Our Investing Checklist

Become a Better Investor With Our Investing Checklist

Master successful investing with our Checklist and get expert weekly insights to help you build your wealth with confidence.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Summary Article

ETFs are convenient but not without risk

Exchange-traded funds (“ETFs”) are marketable securities that seek to track a specific index or segment of the capital markets, such as large company stocks, bonds or commodities. Most ETFs track passive benchmarks, such as the S&P 500 Index for U.S. large company stocks or the Russell 2000 Index for U.S. small company stocks.

Prior to the introduction of the first ETF in 1993, investors that wanted to passively invest in specific segments of the market were limited to index mutual funds.

According to the Investment Company Institute (“ICI”), as of December 2014 there were 1,411 ETFs domiciled in the U.S.

Total net assets of these ETFs as of March 31, 2015 were $2.0 trillion compared to $16.0 trillion in the U.S. mutual fund industry. The ICI estimates there was $1.7 trillion in assets invested in index mutual funds at year-end 2013.

This means approximately 20% of all ETF and mutual funds assets are passively managed in that they are seeking to replicate the performance of segments of the market rather than try to outperform the market through security selection.

Difference Between ETFs and Mutual Funds

The primary difference between an ETF and an index mutual fund is ETFs trade throughout the day on an exchange in the same manner as stocks while mutual funds only trade after the market close.

Because an ETF trades throughout the day, its share price constantly fluctuates based on the actions of buyers and sellers in the open market. That means the market price of the ETF can deviate from its net asset value.

The net asset value (“NAV”) is the value of the ETF’s assets less any liabilities divided by the number of shares outstanding.

In order to limit the extent to which an ETF’s market price differs from its net asset value, the ETF sponsor publishes the net asset value every 15 to 60 seconds throughout the trading day.

If there is a discrepancy between the ETF’s NAV and its price, investors can buy or sell short the ETF while at the same time buying or selling short the underlying securities held by the ETF. Selling short means investors profit when the securities fall in price.

This opportunity to earn an essentially risk-free profit by taking advantage of price discrepancies ensures that any difference between an ETF’s price and its NAV remains tiny during normal market environments.

How New ETF Shares Are Created

ETFs also differ from index mutual funds in how new shares are created. An index mutual fund sponsor creates or redeems shares at the end of the trading day based on that day’s buy and sell orders.

ETF sponsors create and redeem shares throughout the trading day as well as at the end of the day as it works closely with institutional traders called authorized participants.

Each day the ETF publishes a list of securities and their weights called the creation basket that represents the securities held by the ETF.

New ETF shares are created when the ETF sponsor transfers shares to an authorized participant in exchange for a basket of securities that approximates the creation basket.

Similarly, ETF shares are redeemed when the ETF sponsor exchanges the securities that comprise the creation basket for shares of the ETF held by the authorized participant.

These newly issued and redeemed ETF shares are called creation units, and they typically consist of trading blocks ranging from 25,000 to 250,000 ETF shares.

ETF Risks

While the significant growth in ETFs has given investors access to many different asset types at a very low cost, that convenience has not come without risk.

Academic studies, such as a recently published paper by Liao Xu and Xiangkan Yin of La Trobe University in Melbourne, show that the growth in ETFs has increased the volatility of the underlying indices that ETFs track.

In addition, the underlying trading in securities that comprise an ETF by arbitrageurs and authorized participants contributes to volatility in the underlying securities that comprise an ETF.

Arbitrageurs and authorized participants need access to both ETFs and their underlying securities in order to facilitate a smoothly functioning ETF market. During periods of market turmoil and high volatility, however, liquidity (i.e the ability to buy and sell securities) can dry up.

This can lead to large price gyrations in ETFs and their underlying securities.

For example, during the May 2010 Flash Crash some 20% of ETFs lost more than 50% of their value in a matter of minutes before rebounding, according to Morningstar.

A number of ETFs employ leverage in order to give investors two to three times the market return of the target index. They do this by using futures and other derivative securities.

During a market sell-off, these levered ETFs need to reduce their exposure to markets as part of their rebalancing efforts, which means they could potentially exacerbate the sell-off as they liquidate future contracts.

If at the same time, authorized participants are trying to redeem shares in the levered ETF that would require the ETF sponsors to reduce their market exposure even more, potentially contributing further to the market decline.

The bottom line is while ETFs appear straightforward and easy to use, there is a great deal of complexity lurking beneath the surface.

Complex environments can be highly unpredictable during periods of turmoil as was evidenced during the May 2010 Flash Crash.

Prudent investors should be cognizant of the risks posed by ETFs and scale their exposure accordingly.

Related Episodes

What Is a Leveraged ETF?

277: How ETFs are Changing

Ready to get serious about your investing?

Access professional-grade portfolio tools, training, and a community to help you stay on track, tune out the noise, and grow your wealth with confidence.

Learn How

Filed Under: Podcast Tagged With: ETFs

Contact | Team | Topic Index


Darby Creek Advisors LLC
P.O. Box 68544 • Tucson, AZ • 85737

Copyright © 2025 • Disclosures, Privacy Policy, and Cookie Policy • Site by Tempora

Manage Cookie Consent

We use cookies to optimize our website, marketing, and services. 

Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}
Manage Cookie Consent
We use cookies to optimize our website, marketing, and services. We never sell users' data.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}